TOPIC 6 OF 19

Differing Strands within the Movement

🎓 Class 10 Social Science CBSE Theory Ch 2 — Nationalism in India ⏱ ~15 min
🌐 Language: [gtranslate]

This MCQ module is based on: Differing Strands within the Movement

[myaischool_lt_sst_assessment grade_level="class_10" subject="history" difficulty="intermediate"]

Differing Strands within the Non-Cooperation Movement — How Did Various Groups Participate?

The Non-Cooperation-Khilafat Movement was officially launched in January 1921. A wide array of social groups joined this movement, each bringing its own specific hopes and aspirations. While all responded to the call of swaraj?, the term carried different meanings for different people -- from students and lawyers in the cities, to peasants in the countryside, to plantation workers in Assam.

2.1 The Movement in the Towns

The movement initially gained traction among the urban middle class. Thousands of students walked out of government-controlled schools and colleges. Headmasters and teachers resigned from their posts, and lawyers abandoned their legal practices. The council elections were boycotted across most provinces, with the notable exception of Madras, where the Justice Party? -- representing non-Brahman communities -- saw council participation as an opportunity to gain political power that had traditionally been monopolised by Brahmans.

Economic Impact of the Boycott

The economic dimension of non-cooperation proved especially dramatic. Foreign goods were boycotted, liquor shops were picketed?, and imported cloth was burnt in massive bonfires. The impact on trade was measurable: imports of foreign cloth fell by nearly half between 1921 and 1922, with values dropping from approximately Rs 102 crore to Rs 57 crore. Merchants and traders in many areas refused to deal in foreign goods or finance foreign trade. As people discarded imported clothing in favour of Indian-made garments, the production of Indian textile mills and handlooms surged.

Foreign Cloth Import Decline (1921-1922)

However, the urban movement gradually lost momentum for several practical reasons. Khadi? cloth was considerably more expensive than mass-produced mill cloth, making it unaffordable for poorer sections of society. The boycott of British educational and legal institutions also posed difficulties -- alternative Indian institutions were slow to emerge, which meant students and teachers gradually drifted back to government schools, and lawyers returned to government courts.

Imagine You Were There

The year is 1921. You are a student in a government-controlled school. Design a poster urging fellow students to answer Gandhi's call and join the Non-Cooperation Movement. What arguments would you use? What sacrifices would you highlight?

Guidance: Your poster might emphasise themes of national dignity and self-respect, the injustice of being educated in a system designed to serve colonial interests, and the vision of building truly Indian institutions. You could reference the Jallianwalla Bagh massacre as evidence of British brutality, and invoke the ideal of swaraj as something worth temporary sacrifice. Consider the practical concerns students might have -- career prospects, family pressure -- and address them with the argument that true freedom requires short-term costs for long-term national benefit.

2.2 Rebellion in the Countryside

From the cities, the Non-Cooperation Movement spread into rural India, absorbing and transforming the peasant and tribal struggles that had been developing independently since the war years.

The Awadh Peasant Movement

In Awadh, the peasant movement was led by Baba Ramchandra? -- a sanyasi who had earlier worked as an indentured labourer in Fiji. The movement targeted the exploitative practices of talukdars and landlords who extracted excessively high rents and various additional cesses from their tenants. Peasants were compelled to perform begar? -- unpaid labour on the landlords' farms. As tenants, they had no security of tenure and faced regular eviction, which prevented them from acquiring any rights over the land they cultivated.

The peasant movement demanded three key changes: reduction of revenue, abolition of begar, and the social boycott of oppressive landlords. In many localities, panchayats organised nai-dhobi bandhs -- denying landlords the services of barbers and washermen as a form of collective social protest.

In June 1920, Jawaharlal Nehru began visiting villages in Awadh to understand the grievances of the rural population. By October, the Oudh Kisan Sabha was established with Nehru, Baba Ramchandra, and other leaders at its helm. Within a single month, over 300 branches had been set up across the region. When the Non-Cooperation Movement began the following year, the Congress attempted to integrate the Awadh peasant struggle into the broader national movement.

Key Tension

The peasant movement in Awadh developed in directions that made the Congress leadership uncomfortable. As the movement intensified in 1921, talukdars' houses and merchants' shops were attacked, bazaars were looted, and grain hoards were seized. Local leaders told peasants that Gandhi had declared that no taxes need be paid and land would be redistributed among the poor -- claims that went far beyond the actual Congress programme.

Source B — Jawaharlal Nehru's Account

When police fired at peasants near Rae Bareli on 6 January 1921, Nehru rushed to the scene but was stopped by the police. Addressing the gathered peasants, he later recalled how his blood was up and non-violence was almost forgotten -- but seeing the peasants calmer and more peaceful than himself, the moment of weakness passed. He spoke to them on non-violence, recognising that he needed the lesson more than they did.

— Sarvapalli Gopal, Jawaharlal Nehru: A Biography, Vol. I

The Gudem Hills Tribal Revolt

Tribal communities interpreted Gandhi's message and the idea of swaraj in their own distinctive way. In the Gudem Hills of Andhra Pradesh, a militant guerrilla movement erupted in the early 1920s -- a form of struggle that the Congress could not endorse.

The roots of the rebellion lay in the colonial government's forest policies. Large forest areas had been closed off, preventing hill people from grazing cattle or collecting firewood and forest produce -- activities essential to their livelihoods and connected to their traditional rights. When the government further compelled them to provide unpaid labour for road construction, resentment turned to open revolt.

The movement was led by Alluri Sitaram Raju?, a charismatic figure who was believed to possess special powers including astrological prediction, healing, and invulnerability to bullets. While Raju spoke admiringly of Gandhi and encouraged people to wear khadi and abandon alcohol, he simultaneously declared that India could only be freed through force rather than non-violence. The Gudem rebels attacked police stations, targeted British officials, and waged guerrilla warfare in pursuit of swaraj. Raju was eventually captured and executed in 1924, becoming a folk hero in the popular memory of the region.

2.3 Swaraj in the Plantations

Plantation workers in Assam developed their own understanding of swaraj that was deeply personal and concrete. For them, freedom meant the right to move freely -- to leave the confined space of the tea gardens and to maintain their connection with the villages they had originally come from.

Under the Inland Emigration Act of 1859?, plantation workers were legally prohibited from leaving the tea gardens without permission, and such permission was seldom granted. When news of the Non-Cooperation Movement reached these workers, thousands defied the authorities and abandoned the plantations, heading home to their villages. They believed that "Gandhi Raj" was imminent and that everyone would soon receive land in their own villages.

These workers, however, never reached their destinations. A railway and steamer strike left them stranded along the way, where police caught up with them and subjected them to brutal beatings.

Understanding Different Visions

The visions driving these movements were not always aligned with the official Congress programme. Different groups interpreted swaraj according to their own experiences and aspirations -- imagining it as a time when all suffering would end. Yet when tribals chanted Gandhi's name and raised slogans demanding "Swatantra Bharat," they were emotionally connecting to an all-India movement that transcended the boundaries of their immediate locality.

Chauri Chaura Incident (February 1922)

At Chauri Chaura in Gorakhpur, a peaceful demonstration in a bazaar turned into a violent confrontation with police. When news of this incident reached Gandhi, he immediately called a halt to the entire Non-Cooperation Movement. He believed that satyagrahis had not been adequately trained for mass struggle and that violence would undermine the movement's moral foundation.

How Different Groups Understood Swaraj

🏙
Urban Middle Class
Students, lawyers, and teachers sought national dignity and self-governance. They boycotted British institutions, courts, and council elections.
🌾
Awadh Peasants
Tenants and small farmers wanted reduction of revenue, abolition of begar, and freedom from the exploitation of talukdars and landlords.
🏔
Tribal Communities
Hill people in Gudem and other forest regions fought to reclaim traditional rights over forests, grazing lands, and freedom from forced labour.
🍃
Plantation Workers
Tea garden workers in Assam sought the basic right to move freely, leave the plantations, and return to their home villages.
Think About It

If you were a peasant in Uttar Pradesh in 1920, how would you have responded to Gandhi's call for swaraj? Give reasons for your response, considering your daily struggles with landlords, revenue demands, and begar.

Guidance: A peasant in UP would likely have seen swaraj through the lens of immediate, tangible relief -- freedom from exploitative landlords, an end to forced unpaid labour, reduced revenue demands, and security of tenure on the land they cultivated. Gandhi's call for non-cooperation would have resonated because the colonial system upheld the power of the talukdars. However, the peasant's understanding of swaraj might extend beyond what the Congress officially promised, encompassing hopes for land redistribution and total freedom from all forms of economic oppression.

Competency-Based Questions

During the Non-Cooperation-Khilafat Movement of 1921-22, various social groups across India joined the movement with different motivations. While urban professionals boycotted British institutions, peasants in Awadh attacked talukdars, tribals in Andhra Pradesh waged guerrilla warfare, and plantation workers in Assam fled their workplaces. Each group interpreted swaraj according to its own experiences and aspirations.
Q1. Why did the urban Non-Cooperation Movement gradually slow down by 1922?
L3 Apply
  • a) The British government met all the demands of the Congress
  • b) Khadi was expensive, alternative institutions were slow to develop, and boycotts caused practical hardships
  • c) Students and lawyers supported the British government from the beginning
  • d) The Muslim League withdrew its support from the movement
Q2. Analyse the contradiction between the peasant movement in Awadh and the official Congress programme.
L4 Analyse
  • a) The Congress supported the peasants' demand for land redistribution
  • b) Peasants pursued violent attacks and radical land demands that went beyond what the Congress endorsed
  • c) The Congress and peasants had identical goals and methods throughout
  • d) Peasants were completely unaware of the Non-Cooperation Movement
Q3. Evaluate the significance of the fact that different groups interpreted swaraj in vastly different ways. Was this diversity a strength or weakness for the national movement?
L5 Evaluate
  • a) It was purely a weakness because it prevented any unified action
  • b) It was purely a strength because all groups agreed on methods
  • c) It was both -- it broadened the movement's base but created tensions over goals and methods
  • d) It had no impact on the movement's success or failure
Q4 (HOT). Create a dialogue between a plantation worker in Assam, a peasant from Awadh, and a student from Calcutta, each explaining what swaraj means to them. How would their perspectives overlap and differ?
L6 Create
Assertion-Reason Questions
Assertion (A): The import of foreign cloth into India fell by nearly half between 1921 and 1922.
Reason (R): The Non-Cooperation Movement included a widespread boycott of foreign goods, with merchants refusing to trade in imported products.
(a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
(b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(c) A is true but R is false.
(d) A is false but R is true.
Assertion (A): Alluri Sitaram Raju was inspired by Mahatma Gandhi and the Non-Cooperation Movement.
Reason (R): Raju followed Gandhi's principle of non-violence strictly in his guerrilla campaign against the British.
(a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
(b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(c) A is true but R is false.
(d) A is false but R is true.
Assertion (A): Plantation workers in Assam left the tea gardens during the Non-Cooperation Movement.
Reason (R): Under the Inland Emigration Act of 1859, plantation workers were not permitted to leave without permission and were rarely granted it.
(a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
(b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(c) A is true but R is false.
(d) A is false but R is true.
History Term

Swaraj

Literally meaning "self-rule," swaraj was the central aspiration of the Indian national movement. However, its meaning varied for different social groups -- for urban elites it meant self-governance and national dignity; for peasants it implied freedom from landlord exploitation; for tribals it signified reclaiming traditional forest rights; and for plantation workers it meant the basic freedom to move.
Key Fact: The demand for "Purna Swaraj" (complete independence) was formally adopted by the Congress at the Lahore session in December 1929.
History Term

Justice Party

A political party in the Madras Presidency that represented non-Brahman communities. Unlike most other parties, the Justice Party chose to participate in the council elections during the Non-Cooperation period, viewing it as an opportunity to gain political representation that had traditionally been dominated by Brahmans.
Key Fact: Madras was the only province where council elections were not boycotted during the Non-Cooperation Movement.
History Term

Picketing

A form of demonstration or protest in which people block the entrance to a shop, factory, or office to discourage others from entering or conducting business there. During the Non-Cooperation Movement, liquor shops and shops selling foreign goods were frequently picketed.
Key Fact: Picketing of liquor shops and foreign cloth shops became one of the most visible and widely practised forms of protest during both the Non-Cooperation and Civil Disobedience Movements.
History Term

Khadi

Hand-spun and hand-woven cloth that became a powerful symbol of the Indian national movement. Gandhi promoted khadi as an alternative to mill-made foreign cloth, representing self-reliance and the rejection of economic dependence on Britain.
Key Fact: While khadi became a potent nationalist symbol, its higher cost compared to mass-produced mill cloth meant that poorer Indians often could not afford to sustain the boycott of foreign cloth over long periods.
History Term

Baba Ramchandra

A sanyasi who led the peasant movement in Awadh. He had earlier been to Fiji as an indentured labourer, which gave him first-hand experience of exploitation. He helped organise the Oudh Kisan Sabha alongside Jawaharlal Nehru in October 1920.
Key Fact: Under Baba Ramchandra's leadership, over 300 branches of the Oudh Kisan Sabha were established within a single month of its formation.
History Term

Begar

A system of forced, unpaid labour that villagers were compelled to perform for landlords or the colonial government. Peasants in Awadh were required to work on the landlords' farms without any compensation, which was one of the key grievances driving the rural non-cooperation movement.
Key Fact: The abolition of begar was one of the three main demands of the peasant movement in Awadh, alongside revenue reduction and the social boycott of oppressive landlords.
History Term

Alluri Sitaram Raju

A charismatic leader who headed the tribal guerrilla movement in the Gudem Hills of Andhra Pradesh in the early 1920s. Believed by followers to possess supernatural powers, Raju combined admiration for Gandhi with a conviction that armed force was necessary for liberation. He was captured and executed by the British in 1924.
Key Fact: After his execution, Raju became a folk hero, remembered as a leader who fought for the rights of tribal communities against colonial exploitation.
History Term

Inland Emigration Act of 1859

A colonial law that effectively trapped plantation workers in tea gardens by prohibiting them from leaving without the explicit permission of plantation authorities -- permission that was seldom granted. The Act ensured a captive labour force for the highly profitable tea industry in Assam.
Key Fact: When plantation workers heard of the Non-Cooperation Movement, thousands defied this Act and left the tea gardens, though they were eventually caught and beaten by police before reaching their home villages.

Frequently Asked Questions — Differing Strands within the Movement

What were the different strands of the Non-Cooperation Movement?

The Non-Cooperation Movement included diverse participants who interpreted Gandhian ideas differently. In Awadh, peasants led by Baba Ramchandra protested against landlords. In Gudem Hills, tribals under Alluri Sitaram Raju revolted against forest laws. Plantation workers in Assam defied the Inland Emigration Act. Urban middle classes boycotted foreign goods. Each group connected the national movement to their specific local grievances.

What was the Awadh peasant movement during Non-Cooperation?

The Awadh peasant movement emerged in 1920 under Baba Ramchandra, who had earlier been to Fiji as an indentured labourer. Peasants suffered under talukdars and landlords who imposed extremely high rents, forced labour (begar), and arbitrary evictions. They formed Oudh Kisan Sabhas and demanded reduction of revenue and abolition of begar. While initially aligned with Congress, the movement sometimes turned militant.

Who was Alluri Sitaram Raju and what was the Gudem Hills rebellion?

Alluri Sitaram Raju was a tribal leader in the Gudem Hills of Andhra Pradesh who led an armed rebellion against British colonial forest laws during the early 1920s. The colonial government had restricted tribal access to forests for grazing and collecting wood. Raju was inspired by Gandhi's Non-Cooperation Movement but resorted to guerrilla warfare unlike Gandhi's methods. He was captured and killed in 1924.

How did plantation workers participate in the Non-Cooperation Movement?

Plantation workers in Assam joined by defying the Inland Emigration Act of 1859, which prevented them from leaving tea gardens without permission. Thousands left plantations in 1921, believing Gandhi Raj meant they could freely return to their villages. They streamed out on foot though many were caught by police. For plantation workers, swaraj meant freedom of movement and escape from exploitative conditions.

What was the impact of boycott and swadeshi during Non-Cooperation?

The boycott and swadeshi movements had significant economic and symbolic impact. Foreign cloth imports fell dramatically as Indians burned British textiles and adopted khadi. Indian mills received a boost. However, khadi was often more expensive than imports and poor people could not always afford to boycott cheap foreign goods. Merchants initially supported the boycott but many were reluctant to refuse trading in foreign goods permanently.

AI Tutor
Social Science Class 10 — India and the Contemporary World II (History)
Ready
Hi! 👋 I'm Gaura, your AI Tutor for Differing Strands within the Movement. Take your time studying the lesson — whenever you have a doubt, just ask me! I'm here to help.