TOPIC 13 OF 18

National & State Parties, Challenges & Reforms

🎓 Class 10 Social Science CBSE Theory Ch 4 — Political Parties ⏱ ~15 min
🌐 Language: [gtranslate]

This MCQ module is based on: National & State Parties, Challenges & Reforms

[myaischool_lt_sst_assessment grade_level="class_10" subject="civics" difficulty="intermediate"]

National & State Parties, Challenges & Reforms

NCERT Democratic Politics-II | Chapter 4: Political Parties

National Parties in India — List and Recognition Criteria

Federal democracies worldwide tend to have two kinds of parties: those present in only one unit of the federation, and those that operate across several or all units. India follows this pattern. Parties with a nationwide presence are called national parties?. These parties have units across various states and generally follow policies, programmes, and strategies decided at the national level.

Recognition by the Election Commission

Every party in India must register with the Election Commission?. The Commission grants special facilities to large, established parties — including a unique election symbol that only official candidates of that party may use. Such parties are called recognised political parties.

Recognition Criteria
State Party: A party that secures at least 6% of total votes in a State Assembly election and wins at least 2 seats.
National Party: A party that secures at least 6% of total votes in Lok Sabha elections or Assembly elections in four States, and wins at least 4 seats in the Lok Sabha.

As per the Election Commission's 2023 notification, there are seven recognised national parties in India. Let us look at each one:

National Parties — 2019 Lok Sabha Performance

L4 Analyse

1. Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)

Founded in 1980 as a revival of the earlier Bharatiya Jana Sangh (established by Syama Prasad Mukherjee in 1951), the BJP draws ideological inspiration from India's ancient cultural values and Deendayal Upadhyaya's concept of integral humanism and Antyodaya. Cultural nationalism (often termed 'Hindutva') is central to its vision of Indian nationhood. The party advocates full territorial integration of Jammu and Kashmir, a uniform civil code, and restrictions on religious conversions.

Initially concentrated in north and west India and urban areas, BJP expanded its base significantly through the 1990s into southern, eastern, and north-eastern regions and rural areas. It first came to power at the Centre in 1998 as the leader of the National Democratic Alliance. In the 2019 Lok Sabha elections, it emerged as the largest party with 303 seats and currently leads the ruling NDA government.

2. Indian National Congress (INC)

Commonly known as the Congress Party, INC is one of the oldest political parties globally, founded in 1885. Under Jawaharlal Nehru's leadership, it sought to build a modern, secular, democratic republic. Congress was the ruling party at the Centre until 1977, and again from 1980 to 1989. After 1989, its support base narrowed, but it maintains a presence across the country, cutting across social divisions.

Ideologically centrist (neither right nor left), the party champions secularism and welfare of weaker sections and minorities. It supports economic reforms with a focus on social equity. Congress led the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government from 2004 to 2014. In the 2019 elections, it secured approximately 19.5% of votes and 52 Lok Sabha seats.

3. Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP)

Formed in 1984 under Kanshi Ram's leadership, BSP seeks to represent the 'bahujan samaj' — dalits, adivasis, OBCs, and religious minorities. It draws philosophical inspiration from social reformers like Sahu Maharaj, Mahatma Phule, Periyar Ramaswami Naicker, and B.R. Ambedkar. With its primary base in Uttar Pradesh and significant presence in neighbouring states, BSP has formed the state government in UP multiple times. In the 2019 Lok Sabha elections, it polled about 3.63% of votes and won 10 seats.

4. Communist Party of India - Marxist (CPI-M)

Founded in 1964, CPI-M follows Marxism-Leninism while supporting socialism, secularism, and democracy. It opposes imperialism and communalism and views democratic elections as a useful tool for achieving socio-economic justice. The party has strong support bases in West Bengal, Kerala, and Tripura, particularly among the economically disadvantaged, factory workers, farmers, and the intelligentsia. CPI-M governed West Bengal continuously for 34 years. In 2019, it won approximately 1.75% of votes and 3 Lok Sabha seats.

5. Aam Aadmi Party (AAP)

Established on 26 November 2012 following the 2011 anti-corruption movement, AAP was founded on principles of accountability, clean administration, transparency, and good governance. Within a year of formation, it became the second-largest party in the Delhi Assembly and formed a government with Congress support. AAP has since governed Delhi and Punjab, and emerged as a significant political force in Gujarat. In the 2019 Lok Sabha elections, it secured one seat.

6. National People's Party (NPP)

Formed in July 2013 under P.A. Sangma's leadership, NPP is the first political party from North-East India to achieve national party status. It recognises that different regions face distinct developmental challenges and advocates education, employment, and empowerment for all sections. NPP has formed the government in Meghalaya and has a presence across several north-eastern states. It secured one Lok Sabha seat in 2019.

7. Communist Party of India (CPI)

Note
The NCERT textbook lists six national parties as per the 2023 ECI notification. The list of recognised national parties may vary over time as the Election Commission periodically reviews party status based on electoral performance.

State Parties and Regional Parties in Indian Democracy

Beyond the national parties, most major Indian political organisations are classified by the Election Commission as State parties?. Although commonly called 'regional parties,' many of them are not regional in ideology or outlook. Some, like the Samajwadi Party and Rashtriya Janata Dal, have national-level organisational structures with units across several states. Others, like the Biju Janata Dal (Odisha), Sikkim Democratic Front, Mizo National Front, and Telangana Rashtra Samithi, are more strongly tied to their state identity.

Over the last three decades, the number and influence of state parties has grown considerably. This has made Parliament more politically diverse. Until 2014, no single national party could secure a Lok Sabha majority on its own. As a result, national parties were compelled to form alliances with state parties. Since 1996, nearly every state party has participated in a national-level coalition government at some point — strengthening both federalism and democracy.

Key Insight
The rise of state parties has been a positive development for Indian democracy. It ensures that regional concerns receive national-level attention and that coalition governments must balance diverse interests — a natural extension of India's federal character.

Major Challenges Facing Political Parties in India

Since political parties are the most visible face of democracy, citizens naturally direct their dissatisfaction with governance at the parties. Across the world, people express strong criticism of how parties function. In India, four specific problem areas have been identified:

1⃣
Lack of Internal Democracy
Power tends to concentrate in one or a few leaders. Membership registers are not maintained, organisational meetings are rare, and internal elections are irregular. Ordinary members lack information and influence, so personal loyalty to leaders often trumps commitment to party principles.
2⃣
Dynastic Succession
Since internal procedures lack transparency, ordinary workers find it nearly impossible to rise to leadership positions. Those already in power can favour family members, leading to dynastic control of top positions — undermining both fairness within parties and the quality of democratic leadership.
3⃣
Money & Muscle Power
Parties often nominate candidates based on their ability to raise money or win elections by any means. Wealthy individuals and corporations who fund parties gain disproportionate influence over policy. In some cases, parties even support candidates with criminal backgrounds.
4⃣
Lack of Meaningful Choice
Ideological differences among major parties have narrowed worldwide. In India too, major parties increasingly agree on economic policy fundamentals. Voters wanting truly different policy options may find none. Leaders also shift between parties, reducing distinctiveness.

How Can Political Parties Be Reformed — Suggested Measures

The question of reforming political parties is complex. In a democracy, final decisions are made by leaders who represent parties. If all leaders resist reform, forcing change becomes difficult. Nevertheless, some steps have been taken and others have been proposed.

Steps Already Taken

Anti-Defection? Law
The Constitution was amended to prevent elected MLAs and MPs from switching parties. If a legislator changes party allegiance, they lose their seat. This has reduced defection but also made internal dissent more difficult.
📜
Supreme Court Order on Affidavits?
Candidates must now file affidavits declaring their property and any pending criminal cases. While this makes more information publicly available, there is no mechanism to verify its accuracy.
🎓
ECI Organisational Orders
The Election Commission requires parties to hold internal organisational elections and file income tax returns. Compliance is sometimes treated as a formality, and it remains unclear whether this has meaningfully increased internal democracy.

Proposed Reforms

  • Legal regulation of internal affairs: Parties could be required to maintain membership registers, follow their constitutions, establish independent dispute-resolution bodies, and hold open elections for top positions.
  • Women's representation: Parties could be mandated to reserve at least one-third of election tickets for women. Similarly, quotas for women in party decision-making bodies could be established.
  • State funding of elections: The government could provide parties with resources (petrol, paper, telephone, or cash based on past vote share) to reduce dependence on private donors and the influence of wealthy interests.

Citizen-Driven Reform

Beyond legal changes, two other pathways exist. First, citizens, pressure groups, movements, and the media can put public pressure on parties through petitions, publicity, and agitations. Second, reform-minded citizens can join political parties directly. The quality of democratic governance ultimately depends on the degree of public participation. Those who want better politics must engage with politics rather than merely criticising from the outside.

Key Takeaway
Over-regulation of parties can be counterproductive, as parties may find ways to circumvent laws they dislike. The most effective reform combines legal measures with active citizen engagement — the problem of bad politics is best solved by more and better politics.
THINK ABOUT IT — Reforming Political Parties
L5 Evaluate

The textbook asks: "Do you agree that this form of reforming political parties will be acceptable to them?"

Consider these questions:

  • Why might political parties resist legal reforms that regulate their internal affairs?
  • Is it realistic to expect parties to voluntarily give one-third of tickets to women?
  • Would state funding of elections reduce or increase corruption?
  • What can ordinary citizens do to make parties more accountable?
Guidance
Parties resist internal regulation because it limits their leaders' discretionary power. Voluntary women's quotas are unlikely without public pressure or legal mandate. State funding could reduce dependence on private donors but may not eliminate private funding entirely. Citizens can participate by joining parties, voting thoughtfully, supporting independent media, and engaging with civil society organisations that push for transparency and accountability.

📚 Competency-Based Questions — Parties, Challenges & Reforms

Read the scenario carefully: A political party called "Janshakti" has been in power in a state for 15 years. The party's president has held the position for all 15 years and has now announced that his son will be the chief ministerial candidate in the next election. Several senior party members who have served for decades are upset but feel powerless to challenge this decision. Meanwhile, a report reveals that 60% of the party's candidates in the previous election had criminal cases pending against them, and most were selected based on their ability to fund their own campaigns.
Q1. Which challenges to political parties are illustrated in the Janshakti scenario?
L3 Apply
  • (a) Only lack of internal democracy
  • (b) Lack of internal democracy, dynastic succession, and the role of money and muscle power
  • (c) Only dynastic succession and money power
  • (d) Lack of meaningful choice and money power
Q2. Why is the anti-defection law considered a double-edged sword?
L4 Analyse
  • (a) It helps parties win elections but increases corruption
  • (b) It reduces defection but makes internal dissent more difficult, forcing MPs and MLAs to accept whatever party leaders decide
  • (c) It strengthens opposition parties but weakens ruling parties
  • (d) It applies to MLAs but not to MPs
Q3. Evaluate whether state funding of elections can effectively reduce the influence of money in politics.
L5 Evaluate
  • (a) Yes, because parties would no longer need any private donations
  • (b) No, because state funding would only add to existing private funding without reducing it
  • (c) It could help reduce dependence on private donors but would need to be combined with strict regulation of private contributions to be truly effective
  • (d) It would make elections more expensive for the taxpayer without any benefit
Q4. (HOT) If you could design one new law to improve the functioning of political parties in India, what would it be? Justify your choice.
L6 Create
⚖ Assertion-Reason Questions
Assertion (A): The rise of state (regional) parties has strengthened federalism in India.
Reason (R): Coalition governments at the Centre must accommodate diverse regional interests, ensuring that state-level concerns receive national attention.
(A) Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A
(B) Both A and R are true, but R does not correctly explain A
(C) A is true but R is false
(D) A is false but R is true
Assertion (A): The Supreme Court's order on candidate affidavits has eliminated the influence of criminals in Indian elections.
Reason (R): Candidates are now required to file affidavits declaring their property and any pending criminal cases.
(A) Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A
(B) Both A and R are true, but R does not correctly explain A
(C) A is true but R is false
(D) A is false but R is true
Assertion (A): Dynastic succession in political parties undermines democracy.
Reason (R): When family members inherit leadership positions regardless of merit, experienced workers are denied opportunities and unqualified individuals may hold power.
(A) Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A
(B) Both A and R are true, but R does not correctly explain A
(C) A is true but R is false
(D) A is false but R is true

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the national parties in India Class 10?

As covered in NCERT Class 10 Civics Chapter 4, the major national parties in India include the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) which promotes cultural nationalism, the Indian National Congress (INC) which follows secular and centrist policies, the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) focused on marginalised community interests, the Communist Party of India - Marxist (CPI-M) which follows left ideology, and the Communist Party of India (CPI). To be recognised as a national party, a party must secure at least 6 percent of votes in four or more states.

What are the challenges facing political parties?

The major challenges facing political parties in India as described in NCERT include lack of internal democracy where ordinary members have little say in decision-making, dynastic succession where leadership passes within families rather than through merit, growing role of money and muscle power in elections, the tendency to use divisive appeals based on caste and religion, and absence of meaningful policy differences between major parties. These challenges weaken democratic accountability and reduce public trust.

What reforms have been suggested for political parties?

Reforms suggested for political parties include making it mandatory for parties to hold internal elections and file income tax returns, implementing the anti-defection law to prevent unprincipled floor-crossing, requiring candidates to submit affidavits declaring criminal cases and assets, sharing state funding of elections to reduce dependence on wealthy donors, strengthening the Election Commission's regulatory powers, and introducing laws requiring parties to give tickets to women and youth candidates.

What are state or regional parties?

State or regional parties are political parties that have significant influence in one or a few states but not across the country. Examples include DMK and AIADMK in Tamil Nadu, TMC in West Bengal, TDP and YSR Congress in Andhra Pradesh, Shiv Sena and NCP in Maharashtra, and JD(U) in Bihar. These parties represent regional aspirations, linguistic interests, and local issues. They play a crucial role in coalition governments at the national level and ensure diverse regional concerns are represented.

What is the anti-defection law?

The anti-defection law was introduced through the 52nd Constitutional Amendment in 1985 to prevent elected legislators from switching parties after elections for personal gain. Under this law, if an elected member voluntarily gives up party membership or votes against party direction without permission, they can lose their seat. The decision is made by the presiding officer of the house. This law was designed to bring stability to governments and reduce political corruption.

AI Tutor
Social Science Class 10 — Democratic Politics II (Civics)
Ready
Hi! 👋 I'm Gaura, your AI Tutor for National & State Parties, Challenges & Reforms. Take your time studying the lesson — whenever you have a doubt, just ask me! I'm here to help.